Examining the Effects of Anticipatory Robot Assistance on Human Decision Making - Robotics Institute Carnegie Mellon University

Examining the Effects of Anticipatory Robot Assistance on Human Decision Making

Conference Paper, Proceedings of International Conference on Social Robotics (ICSR '20), pp. 590 - 603, November, 2020

Abstract

Collaborative robots that provide anticipatory assistance are able to help people complete tasks more quickly. As anticipatory assistance is provided before help is explicitly requested, there is a chance that this action itself will influence the person’s future decisions in the task. In this work, we investigate whether a robot’s anticipatory assistance can drive people to make choices different from those they would otherwise make. Such a study requires measuring intent, which itself could modify intent, resulting in an observer paradox. To combat this, we carefully designed an experiment to avoid this effect. We considered several mitigations such as the careful choice of which human behavioral signals we use to measure intent and designing unobtrusive ways to obtain these signals. We conducted a user study (N= 99) in which participants completed a collaborative object retrieval task: users selected an object and a robot arm retrieved it for them. The robot predicted the user’s object selection from eye gaze in advance of their explicit selection, and then provided either collaborative anticipation (moving toward the predicted object), adversarial anticipation (moving away from the predicted object), or no anticipation (nomovement, control condition). We found trends and participant comments suggesting people’s decision making changes in the presence of a robot anticipatory motion and this change differs depending on the robot’s anticipation strategy.

Notes
Equal contribution by authors Biswas and Newman

BibTeX

@conference{Newman-2020-125467,
author = {Benjamin A. Newman and Abhijat Biswas and Sarthak Ahuja and Siddharth Girdhar and Kris M. Kitani and Henny Admoni},
title = {Examining the Effects of Anticipatory Robot Assistance on Human Decision Making},
booktitle = {Proceedings of International Conference on Social Robotics (ICSR '20)},
year = {2020},
month = {November},
pages = {590 - 603},
keywords = {anticipatory assistive robot human decision},
}